South Beach cabana or Chill Island Cabana?

[Smurfy 61]

What are the differences between the South Beach cabana and the Chill Island cabana?  Both are the same price, so I'm not sure which to go with. 

[Matt 11,459]

Just location.

Chill Island is a little closer to other things on the island, whereas South Beach is a bit more remote (not to worry, both offer complimentary  tram service).

[dodgestang 475]

Water is deeper in the man made inlets around Chill Island and better/easier to get out for snorkling.   Beach/view at south beach was uninterrupted to the horizon and beautiful....but.....the water remains quite shallow.......perfect for lounging on a float mat

[KJ1231 324]

When do you sail? We were on CocoCay in March and were really chilly in our Chill Island cabana. So much so that I would never plop down money for a cabana again. If there is a cool ocean breeze you may be really cold. It was 20 degrees warmer at the pool just because you were out of the wind. Warmer months are probably a lot different.

[Baked Alaska 1,260]

2 hours ago, KJ1231 said:

When do you sail? We were on CocoCay in March and were really chilly in our Chill Island cabana. So much so that I would never plop down money for a cabana again. If there is a cool ocean breeze you may be really cold. It was 20 degrees warmer at the pool just because you were out of the wind. Warmer months are probably a lot different.

Hmmmm. You have given me something to think about. We have reserved a Beach Club beach cabana for our New Years Dec/Jan 2021-2022 sailing. I may cancel that and just reserve the passes for the Beach Club itself and forgo the cabana. I think I would be cold and miserable knowing that I plopped down $1,399 for that privilege (of being cold and miserable)!