I stayed in the cheapest cruise rooms on two major cruise lines. Here's how they compared, and which I liked better
In:Royal Caribbean and Carnival are two of the most popular cruise lines at sea. Within the past year, I've sailed on multiple ships from both companies, from port-intensive Alaskan getaways to seven-night Caribbean sailings.

Generally speaking, these two lines are more different than alike, catering to diverse crowds and offering distinct onboard experiences. Although I prefer the vibe on Royal Caribbean's vessels, that doesn't necessarily make it the best choice for every traveler.
Recently, I returned from a weeklong cruise aboard the Carnival Mardi Gras ship, visiting The Bahamas and the Eastern Caribbean. She's one of the cruise line's largest ships, measuring 180,800 gross tons with a passenger capacity of over 5,200 at double occupancy.
Still, Mardi Gras is a far cry from Oasis Class vessels. Wonder of the Seas, for example, comes in at 235,600 gross tons and can accommodate 5,734 passengers at double occupancy.

Size does not always translate to a better onboard experience, though, especially when it comes to cruise rooms. From layout to storage and overall comfort, I noticed some key differences between my cheap interior cabins on Mardi Gras and Wonder of the Seas that would make me reconsider future voyages on Excel Class ships.
Here's how my recent inside cruise rooms aboard Royal Caribbean's Wonder of the Seas and Carnival Cruise Line's Mardi Gras compare.
Royal Caribbean inside cabins are small but cleverly designed

Generally speaking, inside cabins are the smallest rooms aboard a cruise ship. Still, having stayed in nearly a dozen windowless cabins on Royal Caribbean ships, I've found that, despite their size, they're usually cleverly designed and functional.
This was certainly the case aboard Wonder of the Seas. Although the cabin wasn't large — measuring around 170 square feet — it was designed to maximize the available space. The efficient layout had just enough room for the essentials, including a comfortable bed, desk, chair, dresser, and two nightstands.
Plus, having launched in 2022, the stateroom was well-appointed with a modern aesthetic and amenities, including an abundance of outlets and TV streaming capabilities directly from your phone or tablet.

Three American outlets, two USB ports, and two European plugs were available at the vanity, while the bedside lamps were outfitted with additional USB ports and standard American outlets.
This was a convenient touch that made charging devices at night much easier, rather than having to leave them plugged in across the stateroom.
My room aboard Wonder of the Seas had a lot of storage space

For such a small room, I was surprised by the amount of storage space we had — from the closets to the built-in shelves and dresser.
The closet had enough hangers for our dresses and blouses, while the built-in cubbies were great for stashing packing cubes, shoes, and other miscellaneous items.
Moreover, the dresser drawers helped keep our swimsuits and undergarments organized and out of sight.

My only complaint about my Wonder of the Seas cruise room is that it lacked hanging space. Consequently, the cabin's singular chair quickly became a catch-all place for beach bags and lanyards to help keep the vanity clear of clutter.
The bathroom was modern and spacious (for a cruise ship)

The modern bathroom was a highlight of the cabin, featuring bright tiles, solid storage space, and a spacious shower.
The shelves provided more than enough room for essentials, and — combined with the added space from my hanging toiletries organizer — the bathroom felt organized despite its size.
Additionally, the shower featured a curved door, rather than a clingy curtain, a small built-in rod to help prop up a leg while shaving, and had amazing water pressure.

As expected, the bathroom wasn't stocked with many toiletries outside the basic bar of hand soap and the 2-in-1 shampoo-body wash hybrid.
On the other hand, my cabin aboard Mardi Gras felt cramped

I expected my room on Mardi Gras to feel small, but it felt even more cramped than anticipated, measuring under 160 square feet. What was even more shocking was that the cabin was designed to accommodate up to three guests with an additional pullman bed.
With limited space, there wasn’t room for any extra seating beyond the bed and the small vanity stool. The vanity itself was also compact.
Still, despite its size and shortcomings, the cabin was modern and clean. I especially loved the ambient lighting above the bed and the minimalistic artwork. Plus, the neutral light brown and blue hues made the space feel brighter and more spacious than it actually was.

There was also a good number of charging options available, including three standard American outlets and six USB ports — two of which were conveniently built into the headboard on each side of the bed.
There was not a lot of versatile storage space, either

Unfortunately, one area where the interior cabin on Mardi Gras felt short was the storage space. The vanity area, for instance, did not have any drawers for storage, just a few small shelves on the wall.
Consequently, the two closets were the only real space for unpacking and settling in. Although they were relatively large, with plenty of hangers, built-in shelves, and two small wire drawers, the setup wasn’t the most organized.
For example, since there weren't any drawers, a lot of our clothing was thrown onto the shelves and toppled over.
The bathroom was small but sleek

The bathroom was far more cramped than aboard Wonder of the Seas. However, it was functional and got rid of the annoying shower curtain found on older Carnival ships.
Instead, the layout and bathroom design are more similar to Icon Class ships, with the shower positioned along the wall, rather than tucked into the corner. The door gives the bathroom a cleaner and more sanitary feel, too.
However, the water pressure in the shower was disappointing and weaker than expected. This made rinsing out shampoo and conditioner take longer than usual.

That said, I appreciated the deep, wide storage shelves. This gave us plenty of room to comfortably unpack our everyday toiletries and beauty products, meaning I didn't have to live out of my hanging toiletries organizer for seven nights!
Finally, like Royal Caribbean, Carnival minimally stocks its standard bathrooms with wall-mounted shampoo, body wash, and a small bar of hand soap.
Read more: 7 things I liked better about Royal Caribbean cruises than Carnival
Overall, I think Royal Caribbean's Wonder of the Seas had the better inside room

First, let's talk price. For my seven-night Wonder of the Seas cruise, the price of an interior cabin for two came out to be $2,292.10. Comparatively, my weeklong spring break cruise on Mardi Gras was significantly less, coming in at $1,702 for two passengers.
The price difference is notable and reflected in the overall cabin experience on Wonder of the Seas, which felt more comfortable and thought-out.
That's not to say my stateroom on Carnival Mardi Gras was horrible. It offered the essentials and just enough space to unwind amid a busy schedule, exploring different ports, playing mini-golf, riding the BOLT roller coaster, and lounging by the pool.

However, the tighter layout and lack of versatile storage made it feel more cramped. It was also a connecting cabin. Sometimes, you can get lucky and have peaceful neighbors. We weren't lucky.
We shared a stateroom wall with a couple who frequently fought during the cruise. On multiple occasions, we heard one of the passengers screaming at the top of her lungs — loud enough to wake us up at 4:00 a.m.
Our cabin on Wonder of the Seas was noisy, too, as we were located at the front of the ship near a crew-only area. This meant that we'd hear crew members prepping for their morning shifts as early as 7:45 a.m.

Still, I'd take the layout and comfort of the Wonder of the Seas cabin over Mardi Gras, even with the sudden early-morning wakeup calls.
Read more: I tried Royal Caribbean’s Wonder of the Seas: Is a mega ship the best?










































































































