The 1970s Royal Caribbean cruise meal we wish would return
In:When people think about Royal Caribbean's early days, the now departed ships usually get all the attention (and understandably so).

But one tradition you'd find on any of those ships in the 1970s or 1980s was the midnight buffet.
Unlike the restaurants that you'll find all over a cruise ship today, none seem to capture the mystique of the late night gorging and excitement that the midnight buffet offered.
The midnight buffet was a culinary institution on every Royal Caribbean cruise ship until sometime in the 1990s when it was slowly phased away from the lineup. For longtime cruisers, we appreciated the new dining choices, but missed the variety and experience that came with the midnight buffet.
What was the midnight buffet?

Unlike the cruise buffet during the day, the midnight buffet was an event and a meal.
Royal Caribbean referred to it as the "Gala Buffet".
Cruise ships before the mega ship era had a different approach to cruising, and one of the big differences was there was a lot less activities and things to do compared to today.

The midnight buffet served two purposes: feed passengers and give them something to do.
Back then, ships didn't have as many casual grab-and-go restaurants. Specialty restaurants really didn't exist, and it was just the Windjammer and Main Dining Room.
Royal Caribbean called it "a pageant of delicious dishes" and encouraged passengers to bring their camera, because half the fun was seeing how beautiful and excessive the displays were.
Food and more food

Typically there would be more than just a lot of food. You'd also find ice carvings, fruit sculptures, and chocolate fountains.
Held in the Main Dining Room, guests could actually first tour the area before eating it all. It was an opportunity to take photos and see the carvings of ice, bread, fruit, carved into exotic animals, scenes, ships. No touching or eating allowed.

There would be a period where the dining room was closed, and then at midnight it would re-open for guests to come back in and actually eat.
It was a combination of dining and performance art.

The midnight buffet lasted an hour until 1am, and you could expect caviar, shrimp, and more.
The best part? It was included in your cruise fare.
Why it disappeared

It's likely two main factors contributed to the demise of the midnight buffet.
First, even the most ardent cruise fans that loved the Gala Buffet recall it being quite wasteful.
There was so much food available, including the various carvings and food displays. They were fabulous, but also a fabulous waste of food in many cases.

Given it was held at midnight, only a portion of cruisers actually stayed up for it and that meant less demand.
The other reason why the Gala Buffet disappeared is because cruise ships got bigger and added more casual dining options.
Other late-night venues were added, such as Cafe Promenade and Sorrento's Pizza.

Big ships brought with them a different vibe, with a focus on late-night parties, gambling, and events that went well beyond the dining room.
It can be argued that the megaships also placed a greater emphasis on the economy of scale that came with them, and the costs of putting on a midnight buffet didn't make a lot of business sense.
By the late 90s and into the early 2000s, the Gala Buffet was extinct.
Why I wish it would come back

I think there's a real need on Royal Caribbean ships for late-night food that goes beyond pizza, and we know Royal Caribbean emphasizes experience over everything else.
In comparing Royal Caribbean to other lines, I think the variety of food served after 10pm is lacking. So I think bringing back this buffet would address that need.
Plus, the Gala Buffet was an event. Guests love those "wow moments" on a cruise, and that's evident when they walk into the Windjammer and there's a large food display, such as a cake or ice sculpture.
Royal Caribbean is fond of saying their approach to cruise ships is a combination of tradition, evolution, and revolution. So why not tackle a fond cruising tradition that could be evolved to meet the needs of today's cruisers with a fun twist?
Could Royal Caribbean bring it back?

While I doubt we'd ever see the same culinary extravaganza that were present on ships in the 1970s, I do think they could do something more practical.
I'd love for them to have a smaller-scale themed buffet, and offer it once per cruise so it can be a must-see event.
Making memories is at the heart of so many offerings on the ships today, and it's clear the midnight buffet is still one of the most fondly recalled cruising memory from the past. If it was that remarkable then, maybe it's time to bring it back in an updated form?
Cruisers today love to experience and share it all with friends and family. I think a midnight buffet would be the perfect photo op that translates to Instagram moments. The sort of posts that would get people's attention because they are surprised what you can do on a cruise.
I think this idea is rooted in nostalgia, but considering how often car makers, retailers, and even Taco Bell dips into retro passions, maybe it's time for Royal Caribbean to do the same!