Perfect Day at CocoCay vs. Celebration Key: I tried both to see how they compare
In:I visited both Royal Caribbean’s Perfect Day at CocoCay and Carnival’s Celebration Key in The Bahamas. Either private destination is an excellent addition to any cruise itinerary, but each comes with pros and cons.

Perfect Day at CocoCay opened in 2019 and offers a blend of thrill and chill experiences. The private island features crystal-clear beaches, exclusive beach clubs, a stunning lagoon, and the massive Thrill Waterpark.
Celebration Key, on the other hand, just launched in July of 2025. Unlike CocoCay, the destination is not on its own island. Rather, it’s on a private area of Grand Bahama Island.
Ashore, you’ll find beaches, a sprawling lagoon, waterslides, swim-up bars, an adults-only beach club, and dreamy cabana rentals.
I’ve been to Perfect Day at CocoCay 10 times, but visited Celebration Key for the first time last month. After spending eight hours ashore, I couldn’t help but compare the two private destinations.
From the pools to beaches, food, bars, and atmosphere, here’s how Perfect Day at CocoCay and Celebration Key compared.
For pools, Celebration Key is the clear winner

Without a doubt, Celebration Key has the most impressive pool of any cruise line private destination.
Oasis Lagoon at Perfect Day at CocoCay is a major highlight of Royal Caribbean’s island, measuring 33,175 square feet. Yet it pales in comparison to the lagoon at Celebration Key, which measures a whopping 275,000 square feet.
You read that right—Celebration Key’s lagoon is over eight times larger than CocoCay’s Oasis Lagoon.
The lagoon is split into two sides: Starfish Lagoon and Calypso Lagoon.

Starfish Lagoon focuses on families. It’s where you’ll find Guppy Grotto, Celebration Key’s splash pad, which also features a two-foot wading pool perfect for younger cruisers. Of course, there is more than enough space for adults to unwind at Starfish Lagoon, too.
Calypso Lagoon, however, is more adult-focused. Here’s where you’ll find Long Necks Swim Up Bar, home to the biggest pool parties on all of Celebration Key.

Although CocoCay’s Oasis Lagoon is no stranger to parties, it’s hard to beat the live DJ set and 166 in-water seats at Calypso Lagoon’s premier swim up bar.
Plus, the sheer size of Celebration Key’s lagoons make it easy to escape the crowds. I often struggle to find peace and quiet at Oasis Lagoon, but I could always find a relaxing spot to swim at Calypso Lagoon and Starfish Lagoon.
However, I prefer the beaches at Perfect Day at CocoCay

Celebration Key may have Perfect Day at CocoCay beat when it comes to pools, but I prefer beaches at CocoCay.
Because CocoCay is an island, there are beaches in every direction. Celebration Key only has beaches on one side.
There are two beaches at Celebration Key: Starfish Beach and Calypso Beach. They are effectively a single beach (they’re on the same 1-mile strip of sand), but are split in half by the pier.
Don’t get me wrong—the beaches at Celebration Key were gorgeous. Despite the cloudy weather on my day ashore, the water was still a stunning shade of turquoise.

Yet I missed the variety of beaches at Perfect Day at CocoCay. Each beach offers different scenery, atmospheres, and things to do.
Related: What you should expect on a visit to CocoCay
Chill Beach, for instance, is popular with snorkelers, kayakers, and swimmers alike. South Beach, on the other hand, is famous for its floating tiki bar, making it a popular spot for partygoers.
The main focus of Celebration Key seems to be on the lagoon, whereas Perfect Day at CocoCay has a more balanced blend of both beaches and pools.
CocoCay wins for food and drinks, offering plenty of included options

Both Perfect Day at CocoCay and Celebration Key offer a wide selection of restaurants and bars, but CocoCay provides a more inclusive experience.
My main complaint at Celebration Key was the stingy dining and beverage rules. For starters, Carnival doesn’t honor drink packages ashore, so all drinks come with an extra charge.
I didn’t cruise with a drink package on my visit, but this rule makes me even less likely to purchase one on future Carnival cruises. Why buy a drink package when I can’t use it at Celebration Key?
Dining rules were ungenerous, too. Carnival limits passengers to one free meal during the day, and any additional food comes with an extra cost.

There is no buffet at Celebration Key. Instead, passengers can order complimentary food at food trucks and at Captain’s Galley Food Hall, the destination’s main dining venue. For an extra charge, guests can dine at a variety of full-service sit-down restaurants, too.
I was impressed by the variety of complimentary food options, such as Bahamian fish tacos and lamb shawarmas, but felt limited by the strict dining rules.
For lunch, I grabbed a personal pizza from Celebration Key’s main food hall. It was tasty, but I can’t imagine it would keep all passengers full for an entire day ashore.

Fortunately, at Perfect Day at CocoCay, there are no strict dining or beverage rules.
Drink packages work ashore, along with loyalty drinks for guests in Royal Caribbean’s Crown and Anchor Society. Likewise, meals are not tracked at CocoCay. Passengers are able to enjoy unlimited meals and snacks throughout the day.
Related: 11 food favorites at CocoCay that never disappoint
Sometimes, for example, I might grab mozzarella sticks at Snack Shack for a mid-morning snack, create build-your-own tacos at the buffet for lunch, and enjoy a creamy cone of soft serve later in the afternoon.
At Celebration Key, I could never have such flexibility without spending extra.
Both destinations offer equally impressive cabana rentals

What I love most about cruise line private destinations is how much is included in your cruise fare.
Whether at Perfect Day at CocoCay, Celebration Key, MSC’s Ocean Cay or Disney’s Castaway Cay, you can have an amazing day ashore without shelling out even a dime.
Still, some passengers enjoy purchasing add-ons to enhance their port day, and one of the most popular add-ons are cabana rentals.
Related: Guide to CocoCay Cabanas
Both CocoCay and Celebration Key rent cabanas, and I’d argue that these rentals are on even playing fields.

CocoCay’s Overwater Cabana at the Coco Beach Club is undoubtedly majestic. Yet the Over-The-Lagoon Super Villa at Celebration Key is just as unforgettable. It includes a sectional sofa, bar, dining table, hammock, in-water loungers, and a private water slide.
There are also cabanas on the beach at both private destinations, but Celebration Key might have a slight edge due to the number of cabanas available with direct lagoon access.
At the end of the day, though, you can’t go wrong with a cabana rental at either destination.
CocoCay provides more thrills, whether at Thrill Waterpark or on the zip line

When comparing Perfect Day at CocoCay and Celebration Key, the former definitely offers more for adrenaline seekers.
You’ll find Thrill Waterpark ashore, which is home to a wave pool, adventure pool, and over a dozen waterslides. The 135-foot Daredevil’s Peak slide is the tallest in the entire Caribbean!
Related: Guide to Thrill Waterpark at Perfect Day at CocoCay
The waterpark comes with an extra cost. Prices vary by sailing, but typically range between $80 and $160 per person.
Other thrills at CocoCay include kayak rentals, snorkel rentals, jet ski tours, a zip line, and a helium balloon ride, all of which also cost extra.

There are a few complimentary thrills included, too, which cater to children. First is Splashaway Bay, which features splash buckets, small slides, and water sprayers. There’s also Captain Jill’s Galleon, a splash and water play area in the shape of a pirate ship.
At Celebration Key, you’ll still find some thrills, but the destination caters more toward relaxation.
There are two waterslides, called the Suncastle Racing Slides, which cost $15 total for unlimited rides throughout the day.

Celebration Key does not offer a zip line. Instead, you can book excursions to nearby Pirate’s Zipline and Water Park. This is outside of Celebration Key, though, so you'll have to leave the private destination.
Rentals inside Celebration Key include paddle boards, kayaks, and snorkel gear.
Between the two, CocoCay wins for thrills based on the sheer size of Thrill Waterpark. Even though Celebration Key offers waterslides, it simply can’t compare to the amount of things to do at Thrill Waterpark.
Both feature adults-only retreats, but with totally different vibes

If you’re in search of a kid-free getaway, you’ll find adults-only areas at both private destinations.
I tried the adults-only retreats at both CocoCay and Celebration Key, but they were more different than alike.
Hideaway Beach is Royal Caribbean’s adults-only area at CocoCay, and it’s known for its party vibe. The exclusive area of the island can accommodate around 1,800 passengers.
Related: Hideaway Beach review at Perfect Day at CocoCay
Here, you’ll find an 18,000-square-foot infinity pool, private beach, two complimentary restaurants, a bar with live music, and a variety of cabana rentals.

Cabanas include the Hideaway Cabanas, located near the main pool, and the Hideout Cabanas, which feature direct access to a VIP infinity pool.
Admission to Hideaway Beach varies greatly depending on the sailing, but you can expect to pay between $40 and $90 per person. The cost includes food and basic drinks like water, but does not include alcoholic beverages, soda, and mocktails.
At Celebration Key, the adults-only area is called Pearl Cove Beach Club. While capacity numbers have not been announced, it's smaller than Hideaway Beach.

In general, the atmosphere of Pearl Cove Beach Club reminds me more of CocoCay’s Coco Beach Club compared to Hideaway Beach.
Related: Coco Beach Club review at CocoCay
Pearl Cove Beach Club features an 11,000-square-foot infinity pool, private beach, full-service restaurant, cabana rentals, and a variety of bars, including a swim-up bar.
The main difference between Pearl Cove Beach Club and Hideaway Beach is the pricing model.

Pearl Cove Beach Club offers three admission options. The first costs $100 and includes your entry and a welcome drink. The second, which costs $140, includes 10 drinks from a limited menu. Finally, the third costs $180 and includes 10 drinks in addition to an exclusive lunch at the Pearl Cove Beach Club restaurant.
Drinks are not included in the admission to Hideaway Beach, although Royal Caribbean’s drink packages and loyalty drink vouchers work ashore.
After visiting both, I wouldn’t say one is better than the other. Hideaway Beach definitely offers more of a party vibe whereas Pearl Cove Beach Club is more akin to the tranquil atmosphere offered at the Coco Beach Club.
Both Perfect Day at CocoCay and Celebration Key have pros and cons, but you can’t go wrong with either

After visiting both private destinations, I wouldn't say that one is better than the other.
There were definitely some things I liked more at Celebration Key than CocoCay, such as the giant lagoon and Long Necks Swim Up Bar. However, CocoCay offers more inclusivity by honoring guests’ drink packages and not limiting guests to just one meal.
You really can’t go wrong with a day at either private destination. Each offers the ability to fully unwind without the need to plan shore excursions or research the port in advance.
Whether at CocoCay or Celebration, you can simply disembark your cruise ship and spend the entire day soaking up the tropical Bahamian sun.