Royal Caribbean sought to make Star of the Seas a nearly identical follow-up to Icon of the Seas because why mess with what works?
I went on Star of the Seas interested to see how the second Icon Class ship could possibly match up to the original game changer, Icon of the Seas.
Because of how much hype and praise Icon received, I wanted to see how Star stood out.
In reality, Star is so similar to Icon that you have to look closely to find differences. That's not a bad thing, because Royal Caribbean got so much of it right the first time.
A new family vacation destination
Photo by AdamsAway
The core experience Royal Caribbean is curating on Star of the Seas is a cruise ship filled with just about every family friendly and memory making option you can think of.
It's clear to me Royal Caribbean wants to build cruise ships that foster experiences that you'll remember for a long time to come. Star of the Seas has shows, activities, dining, and venues that all are sure to capture your attention quickly, and likely compel you to grab a photo so you can remember it and show it off to everyone at home later.
They do this with a lineup of things to do that you just won't find on any other ship.
The Icon Class is built with new innovations that are big and small. You'll be wowed by the six slide water park on the back of the ship that is easily seen as you drive up to the ship, but also appreciate the shorter wait times for elevators thanks to a more efficient programming.
New cruisers don't need to know the differences, because they'll feel right at home shifting from a resort on land to a cruise ship. Star of the Seas is a smooth experience, from check-in to boarding, to dining, and beyond.
So much to experience, being bored isn't an option
Arguably one of the best reasons to pick a brand new giant ship like Star of the Seas is for the sheer amount of different things you can do onboard.
Royal Caribbean includes the most shows, restaurants, bars, and activities on its biggest ships, and you'll find Star of the Seas has something happening almost every minute of the day.
Star's top deck is filled with water slides, pools, bars, and places to hang out. There are two adults-only pools, plus an entire section of the ship dedicated to young families.
The Royal Caribbean app lists activities you can try, including trivia, karaoke, pickleball, guitarists, concerts, street parties, and much more.
Plus, there are three theaters onboard with shows unique to Star of the Seas.
Back to the Future: The Musical is the must-see production onboard, and it's exactly like the Broadway/West End version. A fun musical for the entire family, and included in your cruise fare.
In the AquaTheater is a high dive stunt show, known as Torque.
Think of this like a high energy performance that combines diving boards, acrobatics, music, and swim into one.
At the ship's ice skating rink, you'll find Sol. This show highlights incredible skating technique, set to music.
The shows are equally compelling in different ways, and it's all included in your cruise fare. But, be sure to make reservations early for them so you're not left out.
The only way to be bored on Star of the Seas is to sit in your cabin and force yourself into a temporary exile.
Star is huge, but easy to navigate
New cruisers might be daunted at how they'll ever find their way around Star of the Seas, but the truth is it's easier than it seems.
Royal Caribbean has become masters of building giant cruise ships that are relatively easy to get around. The secret is in deliberate theming and visual cues.
- AquaDome: An indoor space and theater capped by a large dome, offering immersive entertainment and dining experiences (Deck 15).
- Central Park: Open air park with real trees, shrubs, and flowers that has a variety of restaurants, shops, and bars (Deck 8).
- Thrill Island: All things fun and exciting, with a water park, mini-golf, sports court, and many more activities (Deck 16)
- Chill Island: Most of the pools, whirlpools, and bars for time spent enjoying being in or around the water (Decks 15, 16 & 17)
- Royal Promenade: Two deck high entertainment "street" that has restaurants, bars, and is home to The Pearl (Deck 5 & 6)
- The Hideaway: Adults only enclave for passengers at least 18 years old, with a suspended infinity pool, whirlpools, and a variety of seating options (Deck 16).
- Suite Neighborhood: Reserved area of the ship exclusively for guests booked in a suite. There's two dedicated restaurants, bar, and sun deck (Deck 16, 17, & 18).
- Surfside: A family-friendly neighborhood with a kids' splash zone, arcade, carousel, and family-friendly restaurants (Deck 6).
Star of the Seas has lots of restaurants, but many cost extra
Royal Caribbean boasts there are over 40 ways to dine and drink on Star of the Seas, but not all of it is included in your cruise fare.
Don't worry, you can go onboard and find lots of choices of where to eat and drink without spending extra. But the temptation to do so will certainly be there.
The cruise industry as a whole as adopted this model of freemium dining. The basics are included, but there are opportunities to spend extra and splurge.
I think the included restaurants on Star of the Seas are some of the best in the fleet. I could eat at Aquadome Market, El Loco Fresh, Pearl Cafe, and Main Dining Room exclusively and be quite content.
In fact, I think the update to Aquadome Market makes it superior to the version on Icon of the Seas.
But if you are willing to spend extra, you'll find lots of fabulous choices.
The only completely new restaurant on Star (compared to Icon) is the Lincoln Park Supper Club. It costs $200 per person, and lasts almost three hours, but I loved this experience so much. It's the ultimate fancy night out.
My favorite restaurant onboard is Izumi, where you can get sushi or indulge in teppanyaki cooking. It's a real crowd pleaser, and somewhere I try to eat on any ship that has it.
Suite guests have their own subsection of the ship that includes two restaurants: Coastal Kitchen and The Grove.
Coastal Kitchen is akin to a suites-only Main Dining Room, whereas The Grove is a convenient buffet on the sun deck.
Star of the Seas is easily one of the best cruise ships because it has just about everything
The reason to choose Star of the Seas for a cruise vacation is it's likely going to offer everything and anything you'd want in a memorable family vacation.
Royal Caribbean seems to understand the family vacation market better than most, and it's really honed in on what families want in any vacation they take: fun things they can do together that will make memories they'll cherish.
There is no shortage of fun things for everyone of every age to enjoy, and so many activities lean into multigenerational appeal.
With a ship as large as Star of the Seas, you might be worried about it being too crowded. The reality is Royal Caribbean tackled the crowd management issue to the point it's astounding how uncrowded Star of the Seas feels.
Venues, activities, and neighborhoods are so well spread out that it helps keep passengers moving and not all in the same place.
The only time I ever found a crowd is if there was a dance party of the Royal Promenade, which is designed to create a crowd.
Even the pool deck, a traditionally crowded place on a cruise ship, has open chairs and areas to spread out. The adults-only areas can feel fuller than others, but it's hardly problematic.
I think the fact there are multiple, smaller pools that are spread out helps keep the pool deck from feeling like most cruise ship pool decks do. Plus, there are so many loungers and chairs around the pool I cannot fathom there would ever be enough people at once to take them all up, even on busy sea days.
By far the best thing about Star of the Seas crowd management are the destination elevators.
They're smarter elevators that assign an elevator to you, rather than you taking the first available one.
It allows them to move more efficiently and reduce waits. It's easy to learn and very fast.
Plus, Star of the Seas has some amazing shows and dining. It seems to tick every box of what you'd want in a cruise ship vacation.
Who should book Star of the Seas
Royal Caribbean markets Star of the Seas as being the world's best family vacation, but it works for many people than just families.
There's no doubt Star is a great ship to bring the kids, your parents, cousins, and siblings on, because it's the perfect multi-generational ship. There's enough onboard for everyone of every age to find appealing.
But I believe there's enough too for other types of cruisers, including couples, solo travelers, and retirees. Because Star of the Seas embodies the very best that Royal Caribbean has to offer, I think it's a good choice for just about anyone.
I also think it's one of the best ships for someone that has never cruised before. New cruisers might think a giant ship would be daunting, but in truth, I think it's better to have more choices in what you can do, than not enough.
Plus, new cruisers are sure to find Star of the Seas extremely easy to figure out because it was designed with the best ideas and new concepts.
If there's someone who shouldn't book a Star of the Seas sailings, it's probably someone on a tight budget or a value seeker. Cruises on Star of the Seas aren't cheap, and deals are few and far between compared to older ships in the fleet.
Insider Star of the Seas tips and secrets
I've spent 10 nights so far on Star of the Seas, which has given me an opportunity most people don't have to experience it all.
Here are my best Star of the Seas tips and tricks you should take advantage of.
Book shows before the cruise: The shows will sell out, so book them before the cruise begins.
Reservations are free, and should open up about 30 days or less before the cruise begins. Don't miss out.
How to meet the dog: Everyone wants to meet Sailor, the official family dog of Star of the Seas.
There is no posted schedule, so it's a bit of luck to find her around the ship . The Overlook, jogging track, and mini golf course are all places I've seen Sailor the most frequently
The best deals for drink packages, wifi, and more: It's quite likely you'll want a drink package, internet access, a specialty restaurant reservation or some other extra cost item.
The best prices are before the cruise begins on the Cruise Planner or app. Take advantage of these sales, because they can save up to 40% off the onboard price.
Secret bar menus: A couple of bars have food you can order from too, and it's a great alternative to booking a full specialty restaurant.
Both Giovanni's Wine Bar and the Trellis Bar have food menus, and neither require a reservation to dine there.