I would rather see something innovative utilizing the Dining Rooms in 4 seatings at 5, 6, 7, 8
Smaller number of diners at each hour, group dining staff into 2 service teams A) 5pm & 7pm and B) 6pm & 8:00 pm.
Each dining time still receives a 2-hour window, with RC two tiers of dining rooms available there is certainly enough seating capacity
The sheer numbers of people who want MyTime Dining truly tells the story of how unhappy passengers are with either a very early dining time at 5:15pm or very late 7:45pm
As a long time Cruiser the numbers of passengers utilizing the dining room dwindle daily.. to the point on my fall 2023 Cruise the dining room was actually calling passengers asking them to come back as so few were showing up, we were asked if something was wrong ie staff, food... the only thing that was wrong was scheduling. Any restaurant who has such an observable loss of business would have made the changes long ago.