Thank you!! I'm so relieved I found this blog, it has been so helpful since neither of us have ever been to any of these places. We will definitely take your advice on booking cruise sponsored excursions.
Horseback riding: Neither of us are experienced horseback riders, I rode some when I was younger but he has never. I will have to read more reviews on it and see.
Snorkling: Would you recommend one or some islands over the others for it in hopes of seeing sea turtles and lots of other marine life?
As for fishing, we're not professionals but we do go out almost every day. We live in Northeastern Pennsylvania, so it's mostly ponds, lakes and the river. But we would love to test out the ocean, fishing for anything. I'm not really concerned about catching the huge fish such as marlin and sailfish that will take hours to reel in. I think reef and bottom fishing would be awesome for our first time on the ocean. Also, I don't believe we are staying overnight in Bermuda. It says we depart at 4:00 pm.
Have you heard of good experiences going out reef or bottom fishing, on any of the islands we're going to?
I will definitely look into Leo Brown for when we are in St. Maarten.
You have been such a great help. Thank you so much!