Last time we sailed Anthem we stayed at the Embassy Suites in Elizabeth, NJ.  That hotel has a complimentary airport shuttle so we took that from EWR to the hotel.  The next day from Embassy to Cape Liberty we took Lyft XL.  The cost was around $37 (I made note of it in my Anthem blog) and it was about a 20 min ride.  Upon return, we also took Lyft XL from Cape Liberty to EWR.  Also about 20 min and the cost was $40.18. I would say that you are like us in that you would have to get the XL o